A failing shower can look fine for years. The tile is straight, the grout is clean, and behind it the wall is slowly turning to paste. By the time a tile comes loose or a stain appears on the ceiling below, the repair is a tear-out. All of the protection in a shower is in layers you will never see again once the tile is on, which is why this is the part of a bathroom remodel worth standing over.
What the backer has to do
The US Department of Energy's Building America program publishes installation guidance for this exact assembly. Its instruction is to install cement board or an equivalent moisture-resistant backing on walls behind tub and shower enclosures that are finished in tile or in panels with caulked joints (Building America Solution Center). The same guide sorts the common boards this way:
| Backer | Behind a tiled tub or shower | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Cement board | Acceptable | Water resistant, not waterproof, unless made as a waterproof board |
| Fiber-cement backer | Acceptable | Treated as equivalent to cement board |
| Coated glass-mat gypsum backer | Acceptable | Gypsum core with glass fiber facings in place of paper |
| Paper-faced gypsum board | Not acceptable | Does not stop moisture getting through |
| Moisture-resistant "green board" | Advised against | Still a paper-faced gypsum product |
There is one exception in the guide. Behind a one-piece fiberglass unit with no joints, paper-faced board can be acceptable if it meets the ASTM mold-resistance standards, because no water reaches it. The moment the surround has grout lines or caulked panel joints, that exception is gone.
Cement board alone is not waterproofing
This is the point that gets lost. Cement board does not rot, but water passes through it. The Building America guide is blunt: you must coat it with a fluid-applied waterproofing, edges included, or put a water-resistant barrier behind it that drains. A wall with bare cement board screwed to the studs and tile set straight on it is an incomplete assembly, however solid it feels.
So there are two sound ways to build the wall. The surface method puts a continuous membrane on the face of the board, rolled or troweled on, and the tile bonds to that. The drainage method hangs a barrier on the studs behind the board and laps it over the tub flange or into the pan so that whatever gets through runs down and out. Either works. What does not work is half of each, or a membrane that stops short of the corners, the niche and the valve opening. Those three places are where leaks tend to start.
Exterior walls need one more step
When the tub or shower sits on an outside wall, the cavity behind it is closed off for good the day the backer goes on. The guide calls for sealing pipe and wire penetrations and insulating the stud bays before the board is installed. Miss it and you have built a cold, uninsulated box behind the wettest wall in the house.
The floor of the shower
A tiled shower floor follows the same logic with higher stakes, because water sits on it. The waterproof layer has to slope to the drain, turn up the walls and over the curb, and tie into the wall waterproofing with the upper layer lapped over the lower one. Ask your contractor two questions before tile: how the pan was sloped beneath the membrane, and whether it was plugged and filled with water overnight to prove it holds. A contractor who waterproofs carefully will have photos and will not mind the question.
What to look at before the tile goes on
- Walk in after the backer is up and before any tile is set. Take photos of every wall.
- The waterproofing should be one unbroken color from the pan or tub flange to above the showerhead, with no bare board at seams, screw heads or corners.
- The niche, the bench and the window sill, if there is one, should be coated on every face.
- Pipe penetrations should be sealed to the membrane, not left as a rough hole behind the trim plate.
Permits for bathroom work in Oregon
Retiling does not need a permit on its own account. The Oregon Building Codes Division lists resurfacing shower walls, regrouting tile and replacing a toilet, sink or exposed faucet as plumbing work that needs no permit, and tile is on the building permit exemption list. The permit arrives with the work behind the wall: altering piping inside walls or under floors needs a plumbing permit, a new or relocated bath fan needs a mechanical permit, and new wiring needs an electrical one.
Adding a bathroom where there was none is a different job. Portland, for one, requires plumbing and building permits for an added bathroom and notes that electrical or mechanical permits may be needed as well (Portland Permitting and Development).
Which means a shower rebuilt in place, with the valve and drain where they were, can legally go from studs to tile without an inspector ever seeing the waterproofing. Nobody is checking that layer but you.
Questions clients ask
Is green board acceptable behind shower tile?
Not according to the Building America installation guide, which says moisture-resistant gypsum and green board products should not be used behind tub and shower surrounds. Use cement board, fiber-cement or a coated glass-mat backer, with waterproofing.
Does cement board need a waterproof membrane?
Yes, unless the board is sold as waterproof. Standard cement board resists water damage but lets water through, so it needs a fluid-applied coating on its face and edges or a draining barrier behind it.
Do I need a permit to retile a shower in Oregon?
Resurfacing shower walls and regrouting tile are on the state's list of work that needs no plumbing permit. Moving the valve or drain, altering piping inside the wall or adding a fan brings in plumbing or mechanical permits.